• Duterte engaging in risky high-wire act vis-à-vis China and the US



    Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte’s four-day visit to China was packed with drama, including his hyperbolic assertion that he was separating from the United States and that, from now on, “there are three of us against the world – China, Philippines and Russia.”

    However, after virtually throwing himself into China’s arms, the Philippine leader returned to his own country and explained that his “separation from the United States” did not mean a break in diplomatic relations. Indeed, even the defense treaty may remain in place because, he said, “at the end of the day, it is a security matter.”

    Since Duterte assumed office in July, he has successfully reduced tension in the South China Sea and, through his China visit, managed to resume the economic relationship with Beijing.

    Washington has sent Daniel Russel, Assistant Secretary of State for East Asian and Pacific Affairs, to seek clarification of the new Philippines policy. On Monday, he was quoted as telling the media that the US supports the crackdown on illegal drugs – something very important to Dutarte – while reiterating the importance of due process and asserted that Washington was ready to honor its commitments.

    So far, it seems, the Philippines has come out on top, winning Chinese promises of trade and investment while retaining the support of the US.

    Duterte, it seems, is positioning the Philippines so that it receives benefits from both the US and China. It is possible that Washington may offer to increase its payment for the use of five Philippine bases and be more willing to sell arms.

    The Philippines, in effect, is playing the US and China off against each other, to its own benefit. However, this is a dangerous high-wire act and the Philippines may end up alienating both superpowers.

    Media commentaries talked of a reversal by Duterte soon as he left China. There may well be those on the Chinese side who share such sentiment.

    However, it is all a question of expectations. As the Global Times newspaper commented, “Chinese diplomats don’t expect that the Philippines under his presidency will take any radical turns in its relationship with the US, such as terminating their alliance or closing down US bases.”

    As long as expectations are kept low, feelings of betrayal can be kept in check. So far, Chinese officials are pleased by the change from a pro-American president in Manila to one who is openly critical of the US. It is enough for now that Manila will no longer “dovetail” its foreign policy with that of the US.

    And, it appears, Washington is willing to give Manila more diplomatic space. Russel was quoted as saying that the US wants countries to have their own choices.

    In fact, there is little doubt that the Philippine leader has dealt a major blow to the US. By agreeing not to mention the decision of the arbitral tribunal in The Hague last July, which ruled there was no legal basis to China’s South China Sea claims, Duterte has undermined the American-led campaign to put pressure on China to observe the rule of law.

    To China’s satisfaction, the Philippines agreed that territorial and jurisdictional disputes should be addressed “through friendly consultations and negotiations by the sovereign states directly concerned.” The previous Philippine government had contended that negotiations had been tried and failed.

    But while tension has been lowered, the territorial disputes remain and it is unclear how or if they will be resolved. China certainly is unlikely to hand over anything that it controls, such as Scarborough Shoal, although it may well agree to allow fishing in the vicinity by the Philippines.

    It is now inconceivable that China would take any action to turn Philippine-claimed Scarborough Shoal into another artificial island that could be militarized. Even an Air Defense Identification Zone over the South China Sea is now highly unlikely, since China’s sense of vulnerability has been reduced.

    But the territorial disputes between the Philippines and China remain. And their resolution appears as remote as ever. In bilateral negotiations, Manila – if it doesn’t cite the arbitral tribunal’s decision – will have a weak hand, especially if it doesn’t have the wholehearted support of the US as an ally.

    Duterte is certainly right that his China visit marks a turning point. The question is whether the Philippines will be able to continue to play China and the US off against each other. This is a high-wire act and both China and the US play for keeps. Duterte must realize he doesn’t have a safety net in place.

    Twitter: @FrankChing1


    Please follow our commenting guidelines.


    1. Yonkers, New York
      25 October 2016

      The “cat is now out of the bag,” as far as what’s really behind Little Tyrant Rodrigo Duteerte’s neurotic if not psychotic ANIMUS toward the United States is concerned. When he was Mayor of Davao City reports say that Duterte applied for a visa to go to the United States–but was refused one by the American Embassy in Manila because of his well-documented and long record of human rights violations.

      Now as President, Duterte is beating his breasts triumphantly like the gorilla King Kong and virtually shouting to the whole world, “VENGEANCE IS MINE!”

      He has done what his neurotic mind has told him on how to wreck vengeance on the United States, culminating in his declaring to the whole world “THAT HE HAS CROSSED HIS RUBICON, as far as separating the Philippines from the United States is concerned and his seismic declaration in his October 18-21 state visit to China when, before his new Master, Chinese President XI JINPING he said that “I’VE REALIGNED MYSELF WITH YOUR IDEOLOGICAL FLOW,”–meaning, of course, that the Philippines is now a COMMUNIST STATE, albeit a Vassal of China.


    2. Playing 2 cards is not only dangerous , most of the time you lose both. It is synonymous to a husband having 2 wives. The husband cannot please both wives because each wife has a different agenda. At the end both wives will dump the husband due to infidelity. I hope this will not happen to Duterte because he is not the that suffers, it is our people that will suffer at the end. We are still paying the liabilities created by Marcos and to think that that was long time ago. The cost of Bataan nuclear plant is still being paid to this date.

      • The Bataan Nuclear Power Plant could have paid herself out of the loan if only it was utilized for the purpose it was built. Only to be junked because of hatred by the succeeding president which might serve as a crowning glory for the Marcos presidency she dearly hates.

    3. DU30 is a smart man. He sees that the PH can be much better off by having more friends and by leaving the control of the US. So far, so good.