Laude sister wanted to attack Pemberton

First Encounter  Marilou Laude shows reporters a picture of  US Marine Joseph Scott Pemberton she took with her cellphone camera during the hearing  at the Olongapo City Prosecutor’s Office  on Friday.   Photo by RENE DILAN

First Encounter
Marilou Laude shows reporters a picture of US Marine Joseph Scott Pemberton she took with her cellphone camera during the hearing at the Olongapo City Prosecutor’s Office on Friday.

OLONGAPO CITY: The sister of Jennifer Laude said on Friday she wanted to attack the US Marine who is accused of murdering the transgender.

Marilou Laude said she was trembling with rage as she saw Private First Class Joseph Pemberton for the first time at his arraignment.

“I wanted to grab his head and bang it against the wall,” Laude told reporters afterwards.

“We locked eyes briefly but he averted his gaze. I think he recognized that I’m the sister of Jennifer. [Pemberton] has such an innocent face. I wanted to ask him why he wanted my sister dead,” she said.

Journalists were barred from the court hearing, which Pemberton had to attend as a procedural matter before the start of his trial.

Lawyers who attended the hearing and took photos described Pemberton as sitting quietly while wearing handcuffs in one corner of the tiny courtroom, surrounded by burly American security personnel.

After the charge of murder was read into the court, Pemberton asked for the arraignment proceedings, in which he would have to give a plea, to be postponed, court clerk Gerry Gruspe told reporters.

It was not immediately clear on what grounds he requested the delay, but the court granted his request, and the next hearing was scheduled for Monday.

The high-profile case has inflamed anti-US feelings in the Philippines and strained diplomatic relations between the longtime allies.

Pemberton was charged with murder over the death of the 26-year-old Laude, also known as Jeffrey, whose body was found at a cheap hotel in the red light district of Olongapo before dawn on October 12.

Pemberton, 19 at the time, had just finished taking part in US-Philippine military exercises near Olongapo and had checked into the hotel with Laude, according to police.
If he is found guilty of murder, he faces 40 years in jail.

Pemberton was booked and his mug shot taken before the court ordered him returned to his detention quarters in Camp Aguinaldo, according to Gruspe, the court clerk.

Pemberton has been under American military custody at Aguinaldo, after the US government refused to hand custody of him over to Philippine authorities.

The US government insists that, under a 1998 Visiting Forces Agreement (VFA), it has a right to retain custody of any American soldier charged with a crime in the Philippines until the end of all judicial proceedings.

However, the Philippine government has repeatedly demanded for Pemberton be handed over, and expressed “disappointment” at the US decision.

Laude family lawyer Harry Roque criticized the detention arrangement, likening it to special treatment for the American suspect.

He said he has asked the court to order Pemberton’s transfer to a regular Philippine jail.
The issue over the custody of Pemberton should not delay the quest for justice for Laude, Presidential Communications Secretary Herminio Coloma Jr. said on Friday.

In a statement, Coloma said the Philippine government will make sure the US government abides by the VFA and make Pemberton available for all court proceedings.

Armed Forces Public Affairs Office chief Lt. Col. Harold Cabunoc said a battalion of military police and an equivalent force from the Philippine National Police  escorted Pemberton’s convoy to Olongapo.

Pemberton’s is jailed in an air-conditioned 20-footer van at the Mutual Defense Board Security Engagement Board facility inside Camp Aguinaldo.


Please follow our commenting guidelines.


  1. what is she doing there anyway, her dead sister/bro, in olongapo using her body as a bait $$$$. this could not happened in the first place.

  2. I suggest Jennifer Laude’s sister to maintain a low profile on this case. Afterall, her transgender brother is much to be blamed for that incident. By willfully denying her gender on that prostitution binge, it would not have happened. Giving this case much publicity is shameful to the Philippine society to the level of our citizenry condoning an immoral act. Former president Fidel Ramos’ statement that there are more important issues for a public discourse than this petty incident should silence those people who are making a mountain out of this mole hill.

  3. How did Atty Roque get to attend? On second thought, it will take at least 12 months for a decision to be reached in the case to disbar Atty Roque.

    Pero dapat siguro naman, disbarment for Atty Roque.