Miss Universe in a time of crisis

15

I HAD been against the idea of having the next Miss Universe pageant in the Philippines, since the first time it was mentioned by Pia Wurtzbach. A transnational pageant, in all its extravagance and decadence, has no place in a country that is impoverished.

Advertisements

Thankfully, President Rodrigo Duterte said no to the pageant: “Dili ko. Gasto. I will not waste money on that.” (Mindanews, July 27)

This is consistent with the President’s insistence on simplicity, on refusing the pomp and pageantry of red carpets and fashion, of demanding that his Cabinet fly economy, fall in line, like regular people. The President has consistently and emphatically questioned privileged living and ostentatious display—which is what Miss Universe is—in the midst of the hunger and poverty of a majority in the country.

The President has also been consistent about refusing spin and scripts—there is no need for superficiality and fakery when you are talking about the real state of the nation, when you are not in denial about the crises we are faced with.

The Miss Universe, in all its superficiality, in its focus on how a person looks, in its extravagance, in its objectification of women, has no place in the government that Duterte stands for. It is symbolically out of sync with everything he has told us about his government of service.

The Miss U as Tourism Project
The day after Duterte said he does not want to sponsor the Miss Universe pageant, Tourism Secretary Wanda Tulfo Teo had a press conference announcing that it was happening here anyway, with an $11-million production cost to be shouldered by the private sector. “This undertaking would practically entail no expense on the part of the government,” Teo said. She also says this will be “a boost to local businesses” and the “livelihood of millions of Filipinos.” She continued: “If this translates to reality, our tourism industry stands to gain tremendously.” (TheStandard.com.ph, 29 July)

To say I was flabbergasted would be an understatement.

To begin with, there is absolutely no way that government will not spend on a transnational beauty pageant, the largest, most famous in the world—or rather, the universe.

Teo herself said on July 15 that the DOT is “sponsoring” the Miss Universe pageant (Philstar.com, 15 July). How can government “sponsor” a pageant and not spend anything? At this press conference, Teo also mentioned that there will be a franchise fee, which for Miss Universe is rumored to be at $80,000. So, who’s paying for that?

Even just that DOT official press conference is already public money spent on this event. The fact that the DOT is at the forefront of selling this idea to the President, announcing it to nation, is already tourism officials’ time spent away from doing its work: which is to build a tourism plan for the next six years. NOT plan a beauty pageant.

And no, there is no proof that Miss Universe translates to a boost in tourism. In 1994, when we last had the Miss Universe here, the Philippine Statistics Authority (PSA) reveals that there was no “boost” in tourism compared to 1993. Sure there was more foot traffic, but in terms of growth, 1994 was lower (14.7 percent) compared to 1993 (19 percent). 1995 was even lower than 1994 (11.8 percent), proving that the trend was not even an upswing.

On that same Miss Universe year, the Philippines had the lowest tourist numbers compared to other Asean countries like Malaysia, Thailand, Singapore and Indonesia. We were only a tad bit higher than Vietnam. The same rankings hold for 1995 and 1996. So no upswing, no boost.

Private sector money
Teo confirms Henry Sy is one of those funding this production (Philstar.com, 29 July). So, of course, “DOT is eyeing the SM MOA Arena” as venue. And, of course, we can imagine the pageant selling other Sy products like BDO and San Miguel Corp., maybe candidates will sashay down City of Dreams, and be billeted at the Conrad Hotel. They wear clothes and shoes from SM—the best in the Philippines!

When Teo says that local businesses stand to gain by having the Miss Universe pageant here, she’s really only talking about big business—and businesses NOT in competition with Sy. After all, why would anyone put out millions of dollars, without ensuring profits?

Duterte has time and again called upon oligarchs to rise to the occasion of nation, to start doing right by its people. This is the basis of his call to end contractualization, the basis of his insistence that capitalists treat workers better. I’m pretty sure the President didn’t mean for the private sector to make itself useful by hosting a beauty pageant, which is nothing but a profit-oriented enterprise.

There is also this: Sy’s SM malls are legendary for oppressive labor practices (GMANetwork.com, 4 March). There is nothing at all exciting about having big business employ contractual cheap labor for a pageant that has millions of dollars in its pocket.

The worst idea
The DOT says they are looking at five different tourist sites for the Miss Universe pageant. They should also be looking at the environmental degradation of tourism projects in these communities; unprepared for an imposition like this one, these spaces will be left worse-off.

Teo should know very well about how tourism was complicit in the degradation of Mt. Apo which led to forest fires—she, after all, got this job solely on the basis of owning Mt. Apo Travel and Tours. Mt. Apo is closed to hikers for the next three to five years.

DOT should take its cue from the President and stop with the spin. We are losing P3 billion on traffic every day already (Philstar.com, 16 Sept); what will happen to our congested streets and airports if we host Miss Universe? Luzon’s power grid is on red alert: what do we sacrifice of the little electricity we have, for this pageant?

This is just too soon, too ill-advised, too extravagant and pompous, for the current state of nation. To sponsor something so superficial, so irrelevant as the Miss Universe pageant contradicts everything Duterte stands for. This is the worst idea ever, not only for a nation in the throes of hunger and poverty, but also in the context of a government that stands on notions of simplicity and service.

Share.
loading...
Loading...

Please follow our commenting guidelines.

15 Comments

  1. 100% concur to your comment…no offense to the DOT secretary…it’s a good eye-opener for you Sec. Teo

  2. The Philippines is a VERY SELFISH COUNTRY! I lived in Phils for about 2 years and we the Foreigners are treated as your Enemies. Until the day that your Leaders change your Constitution to be IN-LINE with the rest of the world, YOUR PEOPLE will suffer.
    Philippines is the size of Nevada and has 100,000,000 people, Filipinos HAVE NO MONEY, they rely on money from workers overseas (Padala) and from Tourists. Philippines only offer Minimum-wage Jobs or non-paying OJT Training that pays zero or unemployment.
    There are so many ways to improve the economy that Foreigners CAN BRING to the Table, bottom line, it takes Money to make Money. Until bad polices towards Foreigner business ownership (60%-40%) is changed you will continue to suffer, a foreign-owned business will bring better wage paying jobs, these policies changes have been asked by many countries in the world throughout the years, but the Philippines Government refuse to listen.
    Learn from SINGAPORE, they have OUTSTANDING ROADS, great polices towards foreigners high-paying jobs and a very clean country, or Malaysia or even Indonesia, Foreigners CAN OWN LAND!!! And own business TOGETHER or by themselves. ALSO separate Church from Government (as in USA).
    Please do not look at US every time we go to renew your VISA as if we are your enemies, these policies NEVER happens anywhere else in the world: In Indonesia you buy a $20 Stamp and you are good to go for additional 30-days without going through the whole 6-hours Visa Renewal circus in Immigration were you are asked to submit through a criminal-like database investigation.
    Foreigners CAN bring Gazillions of US Dollars and strengthen to your Country and PLEASE WAKE-UP Philippines!!!

  3. Ignacio Balbutin on

    its not the pageant but the gains that we can get from the pageant. Tourism will surely be boosted with this pageant because people from all over the world will be coming to witness it. The poor will benefit if there is an influx of tourist coming to the country. Don’t be so naive, think of the benefit it will bring to the country

  4. January 2017 is the verdict month whether the president’s goal to eradicate drug addicts, corruptions, and criminality within 6 months succeeded or not.

    The Miss Universe competition will serve its purpose which is to distract the hot news of January.

    So lets allow it to happen.

  5. REMEMBER what Kevin Costner said in the movie Field of Dreams”…build it and they will come,” the Philippines does the reverse, “…we let them come, then we worry about building.”

  6. What a timely and beautiful article on a contest without a substance! Even the questions and answers segment are empty words of wisdom. Katrina, 5 STARS for you.

  7. Leodegardo Pruna on

    While Ms. Teo may be having good thoughts about the hosting of the Ms. Universe Pageant in the Philippines, it would be wise to deepen further on the merits and demerits of hosing the Pageant. President Duterte has set the example of simplicity and wise spending. The fact that his first reaction was a NO should have been respected and observed. His people should never ever put him in a precarious position especially in dealing with unnecessary programs which could derail alternative and better programs. The reigning Ms. Universe and the Secretary should not force the issue and instead look at what would be best for our Country. God bless the President. God bless the Philippines.

  8. praxidio buenagua on

    OK na po ito para naman may bagong pagusapan kahit masakit sa loob ng iba. Idagdag po natin sa araw araw na mga nakabulagta na drug related events. May gastos po yan. Si DOT secretary sanay naman po yan sa business kaya di naman siguro magpapalugi sa activity na yan. Let us treat it as a beauty pageant sa isang city Kahit papano nay dagdag na business activities. Tiwala lang!

  9. rudy lagascas on

    This Wanda Tulfo Teo just wants to have her picture splashed all over tri-media.

  10. Boost tourism? Only former FL Imelda Marcos who did it maski laitin pa siya ng mga yellows sa tri-media.