UNLESS Janet Lim-Napoles is offered immunity from prosecution, the Senate Blue Ribbon Committee should not expect anything earthshaking from her when she appears before the panel next month, Sen. Sergio Osmeña 3rd said on Wednesday.

    Osmeña, vice chairman of the panel, said that he expects Napoles, the alleged mastermind in the P10 billion pork barrel scam to invoke her right against self-incrimination which means the committee will not be able to force her to talk.

    “What I am saying is the whole nation is dying to hear Napoles, and they are dying to hear Napoles because they want to hear the truth . . . I don’t think that will happen, unless we offer her to become state witness which means immunity from prosecution,” the lawmaker pointed out.

    Osmeña said that the Senate has the power to grant immunity to Napoles just like what the chamber did when it probed the Philippine National Police helicopter anomaly in 2011 wherein it backed the request of witness Archibald Po to be immune from criminal suit.

    It was Po who linked former First Gentleman Mike Arroyo to the sale of second hand helicopters passed on as brand new to the PNP.

    He invoked a provision in the Witness Protection and Security Benefits Act that allows a witness in a congressional investigation to be granted immunity from prosecution upon recommendation of the legislative committee where his testimony is needed.

    The recommendation should get the approval of the Senate President or the Speaker of the House of Representatives.

    “Yes. It’s in the Witness Protection program law. I was surprised when I read it, but yes, we gave ourselves that power to grant immunity,” Osmeña explained.

    Above suspicion
    Osmeña said that although Napoles is perceived to be the “engineer” of the scam, government officials who reportedly received huge kickbacks from her face the heavier penalties because they took an oath to serve the Filipino people and they should be above suspicion.

    “So if you’re saying, one guy stole P50 million, and then a governor stole P10 million, to me, I’ll go after the governor,” the senator explained.

    He added that immunity is always an option for Napoles, especially if the committee or the court find her as “not the most guilty.”

    But for Senator Francis Escudero, granting immunity to Napoles is not a call of the Senate alone and since cases have already been filed before the court, it is the court that should decide on the matter.

    Escudero also said that he will not vote in favor of the proposal in case the committee would decide to vote on it because he does not believe that Napoles is the least guilty, based on the complaint filed before the Office of the Ombudsman.

    He also expressed belief that the evidence presented by the Justice department to the Ombudsman is enough to pin those named as respondents in the plunder and malversation cases.

    In fact, he said that they do not need the testimony of Napoles anymore.

    “Although it is only an opinion, for me I’m not in favor of that (immunity),” Escudero said.

    Senate President Franklin Drilon, on the other hand, made it clear that the immunity only covers the testimony that will be given by Napoles before the committee. This means that whatever information she gave cannot be used in court.

    “But it doesn’t mean that she will be immune from suit,” he added.

    Meanwhile, Catholic Church officials said Napoles should tell all before the Senate and shed light on the charges that she is now being accused of.

    Caloocan Bishop Deogracias Iñiguez said that Napoles’ testimony can help bring out the truth and do good for the country.

    “She may be a heroine,” the bishop said.

    Also, Marbel bishop Dinualdo Gutierrez said that Napoles has to attend the hearing so that the people should know the truth behind the pork barrel scam.

    “Yes [she has to attend]because she is already subpoenaed and her testimony will ferret out the truth,” Sorsogon Bishop Arturo Bastes said.

    Meanwhile, Bulacan Bishop Jose Oliveros urged Napoles to name names and testify against the others involved in the pork barrel scam.

    “Let her face the music. I hope she will tell the truth. Let her name names. The Filipino people want to know where our taxes went,” he said.

    Jaro Archbishop Angel Lagdameo also said that Napoles should attend the Senate hearing and expose her side of the truth “in order that justice may be served for the sake of the common good.”


    Please follow our commenting guidelines.


    1. Even I’m am Janet Lim Napoles, I will invoke my rigth of self incrimination unless Senate offered me immunity, to tell the you the fact. Sen. TG Guingona knows very well whom the person involved that Mrs. Napoles will try to face off this are not ordinary individuals but powerful clan that can kill you in one minute. So whose Guingona to teach Napoles what to answer and not. Anyway Sen. Guingona will not give any help after the hearing. Give immunity then I will tell all the knowledge or evidence that I know simply isn’t it. Hello Mr. Guingona, wake up before it’s too late

    2. Before she can ever be given an immunity, she should admit first that she is the conduit of all the thieves in both Houses of Congress and return all the money that she accumulated from this trickery and deceit. It seems that they are now trying to brainwash the people and are laying the ground for her eventual pardon.

    3. I am not in favor of the Senate Blue Ribbon Committee giving Napoles immunity. I do not think that there is a need for her to appear in the Senate considering that she might not say anything that will incriminate herself.

      The plunder case is already in the courts and the courts should decide if she is guilty beyond reasonable doubt of plunder. Based on the affidavits of the whistle-blowers, she created fake NGO’s to steal government funds in connivance with the senators and congressmen. She was the mastermind of these scam. The Senate does not have authority to determine that she is the least guilty party and give her immunity.

      It is in the interest of the Filipino people and the Philippine government that the Senate do not give Napoles immunity for her testimony in the Senate.