|
Environmentalist lawyers are threatening to sue Apple
in 60 days if the iconic US company doesn't make iPhones greener or
warn buyers of toxins in the devices.
The Center for Environmental Health
in Oakland, California, sent Apple notice on Monday after
environmental activist group Greenpeace released a scientific
analysis of how Earth-friendly iPhones are.
In a YouTube video posted at the
Greenpeace website, scientist David Santillo claims that iPhones
contain dangerous levels of bromine, chlorine and
"phthalates," chemical compounds used to increase the
flexibility of plastic.
"Electronics companies have
traditionally relied on the cool clean image of their devices in
order to sell them," Santillo says in the video, which starts
with Apple chief executive Steve Jobs ebulliently announcing the
iPhone launch.
"What we have found over the
years is that once you get behind that shiny cover the story is very
different."
The level of phthalate esters, a
chemical linked to birth defects, in plastic coating of iPhone
earphones wires is greater than that allowed in toys or childcare
items sold in Europe, according to Greenpeace.
"If a pregnant woman is
winding and unwinding that cord a number of times each day, like we
all would, she is getting exposed to this chemical," center
chief executive Michael Green told AFP.
"That is a big piece of our
concern."
The notice sent to Apple and the
California state attorney general gives the nonprofit environmental
law group legal standing to sue Apple in 60 days.
A lawsuit could compel Apple to put
warnings on iPhone packaging but doesn't require the renowned maker
of iPods and Macintosh computers to recall devices or alter the
composition of models yet to be sold.
"There are chemicals in some
of the parts that come with the iPhone that are well known in
California to cause birth defects," Green said. "We want
those chemicals out."
The center's experience in
"hundreds of different cases" is that companies prefer to
get rid of offending chemicals rather than taint images of brands
with health warnings, according to Green.
"No sense warning people when
they can just use different chemicals to make it so no one is
exposed to toxins," Green said.
"It's a better business
decision. Especially with Apple, because its brand is so
valuable."
Apple declined to discuss the
matter with AFP on the grounds it doesn't comment on pending
litigation.
Apple products conform to rigorous
standards set in the European Union and the Northern California
company has vowed to eliminate PVC and bromines connected to fire
retardants from its model line by the end of the year.
Environmentalists contend that the
greening of Apple is long overdue, with the company lagging behind
rivals when it comes to eliminating toxins and supporting recycling
or safe disposal of products.
Greenpeace also criticized Apple
for having batteries glued and soldered into iPhones, making it
harder to replace, recycle or properly dispose of the chemically
hazardous power packs.
Green said Apple might need to
heighten oversight of overseas manufacturers it contracts to make
iPhones to make certain environmental goals are met.
--AFP
|