The Manila Times

Opinion

  Home  

  About Us  

  Contact Us 

  Subscribe     Advertise  
  Archives     Feedback  

  Register  

  Help  

  Top Stories

  Metro

  Business

  Regions

  Opinion

  World

  Life & Times

  Sports

  Tech Times

 
 
 

Wednesday, November 19, 2008

 

ANALYSIS

Will Tibetans abandon nonviolence principle in struggle against Beijing?

By Ben Sheppard Agence France-Presse
 
DHARAMSHALA, India: Leading Tibetan exiles entered on Tuesday the second day of their week-long meeting in northern India that could usher in a more radical approach to their long struggle against Chinese rule in Tibet.

The Dalai Lama, Tibet’s spiritual leader, called the gathering after admitting that his attempts to secure greater autonomy for the region through negotiation with the Chinese government had failed.

Before the talks began, he urged the 500 participants to consider all aspects of policy regarding China—ensuring that the thorny issue of whether to push for full independence would be tackled.

Dalai Lama’s frustration

The meeting should air “the real opinions and views of the Tibetan people through free and frank discussions,” said the Dalai Lama, who has expressed uncharacteristic frustration over failing to win concessions from Beijing.

Many exiles feel that his campaign for “meaningful autonomy” for Tibet—which he fled in 1959 following a failed uprising against Chinese rule—should now be replaced by a more aggressive pro-independence stance.

“We certainly hope the cause of independence for Tibet is stronger by the end of the week,” said Tsewang Rigzin, president of the influential Tibetan Youth Congress and a delegate at the meeting.

“I was a bit surprised when the Dalai Lama called this meeting,” Rigzin told Agence France-Presse. “But it was high time. As he says, he has done everything in his power and not made progress.”

The conclave in the northern Indian hill town of Dharamshala opened with the arrival of a large portrait of the Dalai Lama, which was set at the front of the meeting hall. Participants, accompanied by traditional pipe players and drummers, sang the Tibetan anthem, after which a moment of silence was observed for victims of unrest in Tibet—most recently in March.

Middle-path approach exhausted

The Dalai Lama said earlier this month that his “middle path” approach had been exhausted, and that there was now “no other alternative than to ask people” about how to proceed.

Tenzin Bayul, another of the delegates, said she felt it was a moment of historic importance.

“Non-violence is central to our culture, but frustration is strong among young Tibetans and people get very angry about the lack of success,” said Bayul, a 28-year-old activist studying at Tufts University in Boston.

“This situation has gone on for so long, and the Dalai Lama is tired.”

The meeting has no policy-making power—any recommendations would require the approval of the exiled Tibetan parliament—but it comes as the Tibetan movement braces for change.

One looming issue is the health of the Dalai Lama, 73, who had to cancel trips abroad after being hospitalized in August and undergoing surgery to remove gallstones last month.

He has since returned to his grueling schedule and still commands huge respect from Tibetans and supporters around the world—but he now describes himself as semi-retired.

17,000 Tibetans consulted

The talks will also center on current conditions inside restive Tibet.

Before the meeting, 17,000 Tibetans still living in China were consulted, said the speaker of the government of exile, though he declined to say how their opinions had been gathered.

“About 8,000 said they would follow whatever the Dalai Lama decides, and 5,000 said the middle way policy should change and the Tibetan government should work for complete independence,” T.T. Karma Chophel told reporters.

In March, protests against Chinese rule in the capital, Lhasa, erupted into violence that spread to other areas of western China with Tibetan populations.

Tibet’s government-in-exile said more than 200 Tibetans were killed in the subsequent Chinese crackdown.

The clashes were cited by some Tibetans as proof that a new and more radical strategy was needed.

Independence policy divisive

“The only way for us to survive as Tibetans is by holding fast to the hope of an independent Tibet,” said delegate Jamyang Norbu.

“Independence is what motivates the troops. It needs to be our focus.”

But any such policy shift could divide the Tibetan movement and see much of its international support seep away.

A Chinese government spokesman earlier dismissed the meeting, saying that such “separatist attempts will get nowhere.” He could be prophetic—if you give weight to a worry some delegates had over the Tibetan calendar’s description of Monday November 17 as an “inauspicious” and “ominous” date.

In his welcoming address to around 500 leading exiles, Samdhong Rinpoche, the prime minister of the Tibetan government-in-exile, remarked that some delegates had noted the conclave opened on an “ominous day” in the Tibetan calendar.

“We should have been a little more careful about finding the suitability of the day by consulting our own system of astrology,” Rinpoche admitted.

   
 

The PSE-Manila Times Equity Challenge 2008

Phgifts

philflora.gif

Manila Times Friends

Sponsored Links
 

Back To Top

 
 
 


Powered by: 
The Manila Times Web Admin.

  

Home | About Us | Contact | Subscribe | Advertise | Feedback | Archives | Help

Copyright (c) 2001 The Manila Times | Terms of Service
The Manila Times Publishing Corp. All rights reserved.

Hosted by: