• No one in our uncarting country ever said ‘Je suis Maguindanao’


    The most horrific assault on journalists in contemporary times remains the Maguindanao massacre, despite the global outrage generated by the recent atrocity in Paris. More than 30 media workers on a routine coverage (the filing of a certificate of candidacy) were massacred by thugs along with a gubernatorial candidate’s representatives and next of kin. The murder of 30 journalists, done on the flimsiest of reason and in broad daylight perhaps to show the banality of evil, has not been done by mad men on any place in the planet in contemporary times.

    Worse, the murderers were not done after indiscriminately shooting down the more than 50 people in that vehicle convoy.

    The limp, lifeless bodies were shoved into a mass grave freshly dug by a backhoe paid for by public money. But not before the limp bodies were pummeled repeatedly by the backhoe’s lethal hoe to break every bone and mangle every body part. Between cannibals cum despots who devoured the torn body parts of political dissidents they had murdered, and the goons that carried out the massacre in Maguindanao, we can’t decide on who were more savage and deranged.

    Six years into the mass murder of Filipino journalists—and in the wake of the tragedy in Paris—this question is worth asking. Why, after the feeble expression of outrage after the massacre, is the Maguindanao Massacre an almost forgotten issue? No one seems to care that the quest for justice of those orphaned by the massacre is getting nowhere. And that the current storyline of the trial has shifted from getting justice into official bribery and the usual corruption in the justice system.

    Six years into the massacre, not one in Philippine society ever scribbled or uttered the words “Je suis Maguindanao! I am Maguindanao!” to show solidarity with the massacre victims. No one seems to genuinely care that a deranged and power-hungry political family can just be overtaken by the impulse, then murder dozens of people, more than 30 of them provincial journalists, and carry out that heinous act right there and then, as if mocking the civilized modern world that was supposed to govern modern civil conduct.

    No one lost a good night sleep. Not the president when it happened. Not the incumbent president. Not the senators of the realm. Not those weepy talking heads (with permed hair, bloated egos and subpar IQs) who routinely wet their eyes with fake tears whenever a great tragedy takes place in our country. The murder of over 50 people, more than 30 of them journalists, was not enough to raise a level of solidarity and outrage that we have seen in the past few days after Islamic fundamentalists killed the editors and cartoonists of the satirical paper Charlie Hebdo and went on a rampage elsewhere that had killed a total of 17 people.

    The political family believed to have committed the massacre in Maguindanao was able to assemble a legal team so swiftly and prepare for the defense. They even found dummies that pretended to own their luxury cars and massive real estate holdings. And in the region where they had exercised absolute political power for years, many of their fellow warlords seemed to express support for the heinous act with their total silence. See no evil, speak no evil.

    Look at the contrast in the city that elevated the word “fraternity” into the pantheon of their most beloved words.

    In Paris, with a bright blue sky cast over one of the world’s most famous cities, more than 40 presidents and prime ministers marched to protest the Charlie Hebdo killings. They joined over 1.6 million others (atheists and Christians, Muslims and Jews, leftists and political conservatives) to march in silence. There were no speeches, just the occasional singing of La Marseillaise and the hoisting of black and white signs with the words “Je suis Charlie.”

    It was the first time Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and President Mahmoud Abbas of the Palestinian authority marched together.

    At the Golden Globe award ceremonies, the stars fell in hushed silence after actor George Clooney said that the Paris march was not about “marching in protest” but about “marching in support of an idea that we will not walk in fear.”

    Indeed, why has no one in Philippine society wrote or uttered “Je suis Maguindanao?”

    First is that the murdered were all provincial journalists, that condemned specie of journalism whose fate is to be occasionally murdered by paid goons. There was one such murder in Bataan a few days ago, a faceless tabloid reporter paid by the column inches. Not part of the media elite, the lavishly-paid TV talking heads, the well-connected pundits (those read by presidents he he he), the journalists in the provinces and the regions toil under the most challenging environment.

    A displeased warlord can get the cheap hired killers all too willing to kill these anonymous, faceless and unheralded subset of media. Which the warlords often do without remorse. The death toll may place the Philippines on the horror list of the global media watchdogs. But what the heck. No president or national leader for that matter has lost a good night’s sleep over the murder of a promdi journalist.

    Second is that outrage in the country over a horrific transgression such as the assault on journalism is short-lived. Outrage with the shelf life of NFA’s rice, we often say. After a burst of screaming headlines and the shrill commentaries, the tempers would ebb, the font sizes of the headlines would shrink. Every anniversary of the massacre, there is some phony clamor for justice. Mostly just for show and the attendant media coverage.

    Okay, where is the Left here?

    The Left cannot encircle the city from the countryside in an environment where the countryside is a zone of peace and prosperity. The Left can only succeed in a general environment of exploitation and mass misery. The Left’s prayer has always been this: May a thousand Ampatuans bloom.



    Please follow our commenting guidelines.


    1. totoo netanyahu is not a violator of human rights. The palestinians still have it in their law that israel & jews should be wiped off the earth, that they dont have the right to exist.
      I bet you are on the side of these jihadists that behead innocent people, that just threw 2 guys off a tall buildings with their hands tied behind their backs, because they were gay. That stones women to death for adultery, & they need very little evidence to prove adultery. In pakistan if a woman accuses someone of rape she has to have 4 none related males as eye witnesses. Tell me how many people rape a woman when others are around or watching. But i bet you agree with the pakistan law, i think that by looking at wht you write.

    2. I dont know what the answer is but i know all those involved ( & they know who they are should be taken away tortured & just murdered. I dont call these people humans. To take part in a mass murder of innocent people is beyond words or comprehension, & you are right in saying no one seems to care. I care & i would still torture & then murder them today.

    3. Redante Asuncion-Reed on

      To answer the author’s question on where is the Left — speaking from my vantage point of being overseas, in the Filipino community here in the US East coast, it is Left groups that are active and have been active on human rights violations and extrajudicial killings of activists, journalists and others in the Philippines for the past decade or so. In fact, it is the tireless work often done with little fanfare and media attention of groups like BAYAN-USA, Gabriela USA, NAFCON and other advocacy networks that I first learned about these issues — not from mainstream groups. I invite the author to contact me to learn more about how US-based human rights advocates have been active on these issues and the type of work they are doing to keep these issues alive among US-based Filipino communities

    4. Je suis Charlie was very obviously a massive propaganda effort meant to demonize the Muslims. If the Ampatuans had done it for Islam, then that massacre would still be resonating around the world up to now. As for the left, can you figure out why their supremo is being pampered in the Netherlands, and why the ones pampering him are not communists? The left in this country are secret agents of the right , believe it or not. This world is more bizarre than you think.

    5. Sir for info. Frenc Pres. Hollande was angry and did not invite Israel’s Netanyahu, a great violator of buman rights, and was forced to invite the Palestinian leader bec. of the gatecrasher. Many of those leaders who attended the so-called solidarity were HUMAN RIGHTS Violators themselves. ….Charlie? Was just a Show of Hypocrites especially of well paid and controlled media.