‘One Asean stand may stop China’

This photo from the New York Times shows the facility being built by China on Johnson South Reef.

This photo from the New York Times shows the facility being built by China on Johnson South Reef.

10-nation bloc urged to protest land reclamation

THERE is a chance that China will stop its island-building spree in the West Philippine Sea (South China Sea) and other areas if all members of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (Asean) and Japan agree to issue a united stand against Beijing’s sea activities, the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) said.

“In this part of the region, a collective voice is much stronger than a few. The whole of Asia, Asean is a very strong voice. If [Asian nations] can [stay]together, much better,” Col. Restituto Padilla, AFP spokesman, said in a statement released Sunday.

Padilla added that China will likely listen if more countries will speak out against its dredging activities in a number of reefs that are also being claimed by the Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia and Japan.

“Maski na mali kami, kami pa rin ang tama parang ganun ang mentalidad nila, kasi kung titingnan nyong mabuti ang history ng China, talagang ganyan ang ugali nya, ang treatment nya sa sarili nya sya yung sinimulan ng sibilisasyon, siya yung center ng mundo [Even if we are wrong, we are still right, that’s China’s mentality. If you will look at the history of China, that has been its attitude. It sees itself as the start of civilization, the center of the world],” he pointed out.

The AFP spokesman noted that concerns voiced by various think thanks and the issues they present are the same issues that the Philippines has been raising all along.

“It only goes to show that what we have been saying is shared by many and that all nations ought to speak out as well so that hopefully, with that one voice, China will listen and not use might versus what is right and it may as well go by the rules-based approach that all peace-loving nations conform [with],” Padilla explained.

In a recent report, The New York Times said China’s land reclamation projects in disputed territories had created seven new islets in the region at an alarming speed.

“The announcement marks a change in diplomatic tone, and indicates that China has reached its scheduled completion on several land reclamation projects and is now moving into the construction phase,” the report said, quoting Mira Rapp-Hooper, director of the Asia Maritime Transparency Initiative at the Center for Strategic and International Studies.

It said China has built port facilities, military buildings and an airstrip on these islands.

Padilla said other countries are hesitant to speak out against China because they are protecting their interests, particularly on the economic front.

He, however, opined that China will not slap economic sanctions on these countries because Beijing is also dependent on trade.

“Dependent siya kasi sa paglabas ng trade para naibebenta niya yung goods niya. Dependent rin siya sa pumapasok na goods na kailangan niya para mag-produce so give and take yan, so pag naging solitary economic unit lang siya, hindi siya magpo-prosper [Because China is also dependent on trade right? It needs other nations to be able to sell its goods. It is also dependent on the goods that are coming in [from other countries]. So it is just give and take. If it becomes a solitary economic unit, it will not prosper],” Padilla said

While the G7 or Group of 7 that is comprised of Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, the United Kingdom and the United States have spoken against China’s unilateral actions such as large-scale reclamations in disputed waterways, the AFP spokesman also noted that the Asean had been silent on the issue.

“[That is our challenge. Asean should have one solid voice],” the AFP official said.

Last month, the Philippines sent a delegation to The Hague to convince a United Nations-backed international tribunal to take jurisdiction of the complaint filed by Manila challenging China’s claim to almost the entire West Philippine Sea.

The Philippines and fellow Asean members Brunei Darussalam, Malaysia and Vietnam have competing claims to South China Sea areas along with China and Taiwan.

The dispute grew increasingly tense in recent years with the Philippines at the forefront of accusing China of “bullying” in asserting its claim to the South China Sea, a crucial lane and fishing ground also believed to hold vast mineral resources.

In recent months, the Philippines had raised the alarm over China’s land reclamation to turn outcroppings in the sea into artificial islands that can host military outposts.

Asean, which also includes Indonesia, Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar, Singapore and Thailand, has been pushing for the establishment of a “Code of Conduct” with China that would bind the rival claimants not to take actions that could spark conflict in the region.

Despite their appeal for unity, Asean members have diverging agendas, and the bloc has had difficulty taking a common stand on China, which has close relationships with several members.

Also on Sunday, the Department of Foreign Affairs (DFA) said Asean and China are discussing setting up a “hotline” in case of an emergency regarding the territorial disputes.

The proposed hotline was discussed during a meeting of senior diplomats from China and Asean in Tianjin last week, Charles Jose, DFA spokesman, said.

Jose added that the matter had been referred back to a joint working group and was still far from fruition.

“Although this was agreed in principle as an early harvest measure, it needs thorough discussion,” he said in a statement.

Jose added that the hotline will not be unveiled at an upcoming meeting of Asean foreign ministers.

Experts, however, said Asean should look at the bigger context of its ties with China and not be bogged down by the territorial disputes in the South China Sea.

“The territorial flashpoints in the South China Sea are not going away, but then again Asean-China relations have always been more than just the South China Sea,” Benjamin Ho, a maritime security researcher, said.

Ho, associate research fellow at the Institute of Defense and Strategic Studies, Nanyang Technological University of Singapore, said the Asean-China relations are largely very stable at the moment.

Such ties were further strengthened with the Asean support for the recent Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank initiative by the world’s second largest economy.

Ho said having a “Code of Conduct”or COC will certainly help clarify interests of the respective countries.

Nonetheless, a COC does not guarantee that tensions will ease among the parties, which have interests in the area involving two island chains — the Paracels and the Spratlys, a major shipping route and home to fishing grounds that contribute to the livelihoods of people across the region.

Meanwhile, Universiti Sains Malaysia’s (USM) Center for Global Sustainability Studies director Dr. Kamarulazizi Ibrahim said there was a need for Asean to extend further its friendship to China, which could provide a platform for Asean members to discuss with dialogue partners on issues surrounding the South China Sea.

Kamarulazizi said the members of Asean, whose population is about 600 million, need to sit and discuss the territorial claims, not only those affecting borders but economic activities like fishery, shipping routes as well as safety of the area.

“We should project to China that the Asean region is a growing economy, where China is also benefiting from the rapid growth. Asean needs to promote its success and show the superpower the bloc’s rapid improvement,” he added.

Meanwhile, USM Pro-Chancellor Tan Sri Mustafa Mansur said Asean members should work cohesively for solidarity in addressing the South China Sea disputes.

“We have to be very careful in handling this matter,” added the former president of the Federation of Malaysian Manufacturers.



Please follow our commenting guidelines.


  1. Mariano Patalinjug on

    Yonkers, New York
    03 August 2015

    In a previous confab, the ASEAN tried to get all members to agree to a Code of Conduct for all members–which of course includes China.

    But one nation torpedoed the effort–and explains why the ASEAN failed.

    Now comes this same proposal on a Code of Conduct in this present confab of ASEAN.

    I am afraid that there will not be a consensus again, because one nation may fear how China will react.

    You can say that the ASEAN is a paper tiger, afraid to do what’s right, because one member is afraid of China.


  2. Does the AFP has its head in the sand reefs?
    Other ASEAN nations are also contesting those atolls/reefs what not!

  3. Nothing short of an allied armed response will stop China. Much like the Munich accord signed by England and violated shortly thereafter by Germany, Peace is not at hand. ASEAN nations should combined their forces and kick the Chinese out.

  4. Yung nakaraan na ASEAN Summit sa Singapore me pumanig ba sa Pilipinas among the ASEAN Countries at si Pnoy mismo ang nagsabi sa kanila about China’s aggressiveness sa atin? Wala di ba? Kaya yan mga ibang ASEAN Countries ay mga tuta ng china. Pinahiya pa nga si Pnoy sa FB ng taga Singapore sa pag late Nya sa pictorial.

  5. China is not going to listen. It’s to late now, they have completed the majority of the construction. They will rule the whole area from Okinawa south. Anything short of a war involving the USA China will continue to dominate.

  6. Joint Asean Naval patrol group is what we need to stop china’s illegal invasion of the South China Sea. . .