• People Surge: ‘No-build zones’ to enrich the elite

    Giovanni Tapang, Ph.D.

    Giovanni Tapang, Ph.D.

    Marking one hundred days after Yolanda (Haiyan) struck Samar and Leyte, members of People Surge trooped to Metro Manila to highlight their situation and bring their petition for financial assistance and a stop to the “no-build-zone” policy affecting many coastal communities.

    People’s Surge was formed last January 24 to 25 in Tacloban City when more than 13,000 protesters mobilized in downtown Tacloban to demand government action on the plight of the affected victims in the region. That was one of the biggest mass demonstration seen in Eastern Visayas in recent years. One of their main demands was a demand for P40,000 financial assistance for families that were affected by the typhoon.

    Sister Edita Espolor, spokesperson for People’s Surge, pointed out that more than three months have already passed and people of Eastern Visayas are still in need of, and are still demanding, food, livelihood, housing and social services. She echoed the uncertainty that the people in the region are feeling happy, contented and at peace as many victims are still struggling under their very difficult situation until now.

    They are coming to Manila to assert that government planners should put the people at the center of any post-Yolanda rehabilitation plan. Despite an estimated cost of P360 billion by the National Economic and Development Authority, a clear plan for recovery and reconstruction is still not at hand. What they hear about are big plans for public-private partnerships between big foreign and local businesses that are eyeing projects in the area.

    People Surge made its own study on the estimated damage of typhoon Yolanda in Eastern Visayas and lists the following: more than two million farmers and fisherfolk were affected and total agricultural damage estimates reach up to P 64 billion. As more than 80 percent of the population in the area is reliant on agricultural activity, Yolanda’s destruction is being shouldered directly by the peasants affected by the storm.

    Sr. Espolor said that the rural poor who are already living at subsistence level are being forced deeper in poverty with no foreseeable income in the future. Urban poor families are barred from returning to their communities due to the “no build zone” policy and are crammed into substandard bunkhouses. Espolor noted that many of these bunkhouses are not finished as of today.

    Worse, the “no build zones” where the urban poor in Tacloban is being denied entry are the same areas where supposed investment zones are being offered to big business and inventors. Taken under this light, these “no-build zones” are just being used to clear the area not for safety’s sake but for other interests.

    Mangrove specialist Prof. Jurgenne Primavera pointed out in a forum at UP Diliman last year that coastal protection should involve not only hard engineering—seawalls, levees and breakwaters—but should also include rebuilding beaches and mangrove forests as well. She further pointed out that despite the many greenbelt laws that require buffer zones facing the open sea and riverbanks, “pond after fishpond in monotonous succession with hardly any relief of green” are more the norm than compliance with the law.

    In considering the overall rehabilitation of the area, the government should not hide behind the no-build zones in driving away urban poor families from their communities as they have not given any alternative free housing for them before—and after—Typhoon Yolanda. Worse, government has allowed many reclamation activities in Manila Bay and other areas in direct contradiction to its supposed no-build zone policy.

    Professor Primavera has one suggestion in an opinion piece she wrote some months ago. She suggests that government purchase land for the resettlement of low-income fishers and other coastal folk with no resources to move out of harm’s way.

    Before they are driven away from their lands, government should first ensure alternative housing, jobs, access to resources and support for our displaced people rather than their one-minded view of just clearing them away for the supposed investors to come in.

    A more comprehensive study on how to put up buffer zones against these storm surges and flooding should be done before blindly driving people away especially those that were left with nothing because of Yolanda. In the immediate, Sr. Espolor suggests that government first ensure the food security of the peasants by promoting quick-growing cash crops so they could recover lost income and to provide the necessary agricultural assistance to sustain them in the long term.

    Sr. Espolor and her companions tried to bring this to Malacañang in a letter but many of them were denied entrance to the Palace. This is accompanied by petition papers that were signed by more than 17,500 individuals. The same cold welcome happened in Leyte where members of People Surge pressed for a dialogue with the authorities tasked for rehabilitation of the region. Despite beng tasked by the President to head the task force for Eastern Visayas, reports say that no dialogue took place between Secretary Jericho Petilla since he was “too busy and can only meet them in March.”

    If the government keeps to this mindset of pushing the people of Eastern Visayas away from participating in the planning and implementation of the rehabilitation of their area, the large mobilizations in Tacloban is a portent of the aptly named people’s surge that might come.


    Please follow our commenting guidelines.


    1. It was never in his plan. Aquino and his government do not give a hoot. Come 2016 the same folks will still elect his sister as Senator and the same old faces will be in govt. Who knows come 2020 the same folks will elect his sister to be president of the philippines. Such is the lot of us. What they can not get in votes they have the PCOS, the cousin owned Poll Surveys and of course the Media duly owned by his neighbours in Forbes Park.

    2. Blah blah blah blah blah definitely did not save lives. All that noynoy did is to go on national television to warn the people of the extreme danger of super typhoon Yolanda. Then BS Aquino on Nov. 7 assured the public of the government’s readiness to face supertyphoon “Yolanda” which will directly hit Samar and Leyte at midnight. According to noynoy, PH ready to face supertyphoon ‘Yolanda’.

      According to the Constitution, the prime duty of the Government is to serve and protect the people.But noynoy government failed miserably to do its prime duty to serve and protect the people. Noynoy must be held responsible for the death of more than 6,000 Yolanda victims for doing nothing to evacuate the people to safer grounds and save them from certain death, from the death trap of very strong Tsunami-like force of the storm surges.

      Actions could have save thousands of lives like mobilizing the military soldiers to force evacuate the people to safer grounds away from the killer storm surges. According to the Constitution, the Armed Forces of the Philippines is the protector of the people but their Commander-in-Chief did nothing for the protection of life. In Vietnam, their military soldiers evacuated 90,000 Vietnamese while super typhoon Haiyan is still far away. But here in the Philippines, the noynoying government did not mobilized our brave and heroic soldiers of the AFP. The people were left on their own to find safer grounds. Bahala na silang magligtas ng kanilang mga sarili. Hindi inutusan ni noynoy ang ating mga sundalo para ilikas sa panganib ang mamamayan. Why? Dahil ba hindi kaalyado at kaibigan ni noynoy ang local government? Is it a valid excuse to blame the local government? Nope. I truly do not think so. Noynoy must be held responsible for the death of more than 6,000 Filipinos as a result of his action and/or inaction as president of our nation. Anong halaga ng ating Saligang Batas kung hindi naman ito sinusunod?

    3. The President is going to visit their respective places next week. Those townfolks that woulde be visited by Abnoy should likewise give him a cold shoulder treatment by vehemently protesting and not welcoming him like a conquering hero who is bringing with him the needed relief that they badly want. It will only be all for show because of the snub that Abnoy committed during the recent rally they had at the Palace.

    4. Imperial Manila is intent on lording over insignicant (to them) Visayans. The reality in the Phl is you have to shout to be heard, you have to demand to be considered, you have to march in numbers to be taken seriously. People Surge must be louder and bigger.