Shooting the messenger


Poor Chief Superintendent Elmer Soria. Until several days ago, he was police commander for Eastern Visayas. Now he’s been unceremoniously reassigned to a desk job at PNP headquarters in Camp Crame.

What cost the chief superintendent his job was an estimate he gave of the number of deaths from Yolanda that tore across central Philippines on November 8. He told reporters that the super typhoon could have killed as many as 10,000 people, culling initial reports from police and local officials.

The figure drew a quick response from President Benigno Aquino 3rd. It’s way too high, the President said. A more realistic estimate was 2,000 to 2,500, he said.

Chief Superintendent Soria must have been suffering from “emotional trauma” when he quoted the officials who themselves “did not have a basis for it,” Mr. Aquino said.

Soon after, Camp Crame announced that Soria was being relieved of his command and will undergo “a stress debriefing because of the trauma that he may have experienced on the ground during the typhoon.”

The government could have crafted a more believable explanation for sacking Soria than claiming he was emotionally overwhelmed by the tragedy Yolanda had brought.

So what did Soria do for him to deserve such a sanction?

The police officer simply made the mistake of embarrassing the President, although we are sure Soria never meant to. Mr. Aquino has been obsessed with keeping a “zero casualty” count during natural calamities. He has woven his administration’s disaster preparedness program around it.

A death toll of 10,000 derides the zero casualty policy. It is unacceptable because it indicates that the government’s much-vaunted disaster preparedness program failed miserably.

But the President is forgetting that Yolanda is no ordinary storm. It is the strongest ever recorded to hit land. Even before Yolanda struck the country, weather experts were warning that its effects would be catastrophic.

Indeed, the scale of destruction is something the country has never experienced before. The complete picture of the tragedy is still unfolding; the casualty and damage figures are still rising.

Already the official number of dead is inching is about to breach 4,000. That’s far beyond the President’s estimate.

What happens if the number comes close to 10,000? Would the President acknowledge that Soria was right all along and absolve him?

The Soria episode adds to the many missteps of the Aquino administration as it struggles with the humanitarian crisis in Yolanda’s aftermath. Already the government is reeling from a barrage of criticism for the slowness in delivering food and other relief goods to the people who need it most. There is also an outcry over the lack of competent leaders on the ground to supervise relief efforts. Order has not been completely restored in many ravaged areas, and reports of rapes and looting are on the rise.

President Aquino is doing his best to cope with the unprecedented tragedy that has shaken the nation, that much is certain. But this is not the time for knee-jerk decisions that only feed the people’s anger and frustration. The decision to relieve Chief Superintendent Elmer Soria is one such decision. Soria could have been quietly admonished to be more prudent with his remarks next time. To remove him outright from his post was an overreaction, and to explain that he needs to be treated for emotional trauma insults the intellect.


Please follow our commenting guidelines.


  1. Pinoy Makabayan on

    Even Anderson Coper noticed it and announced it to the world that our leaders seem to be more concerned with their image than caring for their people. He hit the nail right on his head! Kung may differencia yang si Aquino, yun kanyang obsession with himself! The vice president naman, e-paling, redaying himself for the 2016 election like Mar Roxas. This is the worse tragedy for any nation, unprecedented. Wala nang sasama dito,pareho na nila si Hitler sa kasamaan!

  2. Si Noynoy ay hindi isang tao para sa mga tao. Mas mahalaga sa kanya na pagandahin ang kanyang imahen kaysa pagandahin ang buhay ng mga tao.

  3. Ito ang sinasabi na s Noynoy ay isang tao para sa mga tao. Mas mahalaga sa kanya ang kanya na pagandahin ang kanyang imahen kaysa pagandahin ang buhay ng mga tao.

  4. The disaster and calamity in the name of Benigno Simeon Aquino III is unstoppable, Lord help us. What have we done to deserve your punishment.

  5. It is the Tenant himself, BS…A 3 who was diagnosed to have a psychological deficit of a trauma in childhood according to many published accounts and observationsthat are now manifested in his ” uncaring, unconcerned, and insensitive” actions and reactions to many side issues engendered by the Yolanda devastation. His determined effort to exact vendetta to all those who have wronged him or crossed him in whatever way or manner has earned him the moniker “Boy Sisi” and his very obvious display of lack of capacity for empathy and genuine concern for those who suffered the devastation very poor inter-personal relationship with others are now seen and perceived as real psychological aberrations. Fr Jaime Bulatao, S.J. was first reported as having made this official clinical evaluation. Why not make this public as there is an explicit requirement for the highest position of the land to be mature and sane, at the very least? The elder Carandangs, husband and wife are in the medical field, should also be privy to this deficit of the Tenant. The patient-doctor confidentiality cannot be invoked when the security interests of the State is at stake.