Strip Purisima of his 4th star


THE undated resignation letter of Purisima was a resignation from the position of Chief Philippine National Police (CPNP) and not a resignation from the service.

This means he remains in the roster of the PNP until he reaches the PNP’s mandatory retirement age of fifty-six (56). Purisima will reach 56 only on November 21. And since only the CPNP can have four stars, there can be no full time CPNP until Purisima retires or the 4th star is stripped of Purisima. Purisima has shamed the institution and the uniform he wears, he should be stripped of his 4th star now.

This is unlike the case of former PNP chief Director General Nicanor Bartolome, who retired in March 2013 but went on a “no-duty” status before the end of 2012 to pave the way for an early transition to a new PNP boss. Purisima took over from Bartolome. The reason given to the early exit of Bartolome was the mid-term elections of May 2013. The “no-duty” plan resulted in Bartolome relinquishing his administrative and operational duties to a new PNP chief before the year ended. Bartolome continued to hold on to his rank as a 4-star director general until his retirement in March. Bartolome retired, Purisima resigned.

Purisima is a unique case because he is serving a preventive suspension by the Ombudsman and he resigned because of violating such order and getting himself involved in the planning and operations of Oplan Exodus in Mamasapano. Purisima violated the Ombudsman’s order, had 44 SAF killed and “advised” knowingly and willfully BSA3 on Oplan Exodus despite his status. What aggravates Purisima’s advice was that he never had any assignment in any part of Mindanao in his entire career. Purisima had no deep knowledge of the terrain, the people and the customs and traditions in Mindanao.

Clearly, the appointment of Deputy Chief Leo Espina was merely as an officer-in-charge and not as acting chief, unlike DOH Secretary Janet Garin who was given an acting appointment. Clearly, the intention was, after serving the preventive suspension, Purisima would be back at the helm to finish his term. Unfortunately, the Rule of Law was compromised because of the Barkada mentality that has pervaded the bureaucracy. That Purisima was closed to the appointing authority was a major factor and that no one from among the official family of the security cluster can tell the King of 44 lives lost was telling. No one but no one can ask BSA3 much less inform him of the suicide mission that speaks so much of the kind of government we now have today. Whatever happened to the Liberal Party stalwarts who convinced Sen. Aquino to run for the presidency? You can’t even be a patriot to the men in uniform and to this country, truly you will reap what you sow.

Has any general been stripped of his star? There seems to be none in the Philippines. But in recent memory, there was former head of the US Africa Command, US Armed Forces, Gen. William “Kip” Ward. He was “stripped of a star by Defense Secretary Leon Panetta after an internal investigation revealed that he had inappropriately spent tens of thousands of dollars of taxpayer money for lavish personal vacations and expenses.”

Gen. Ward, an African American, had already stepped down as head of the new Africa Command but he was stopped from retiring—after he had already held a retirement ceremony in April 2011—by Panetta until the Army investigation was completed.

A report by the Department of Defense Inspector General’s Office, released in August, accused Ward of misusing his position, his subordinates’ time, government funds, and rental vehicles. Ward allowed unauthorized people, including family members, to fly on government planes, and spent excessive amounts of money on hotel rooms, transportation and other expenses when he traveled as head of Africa Command. The general even allowed his wife to use military vehicles to shop and visit spas, and he billed the government for a refueling stop overnight in Bermuda, where the couple stayed in a $750 suite—for a trip whose cost exceeded $10,700 for his party of 12, staff and the aircrew. In addition, in January 2011 Ward allegedly took an 11-day trip to Washington and Atlanta with an entourage of 13 military and civilian personnel which cost $129,000, and he conducted less than three days of official business, the report states.

After the release of the report, Panetta stripped Ward of a star so that he will now retire as a three-star lieutenant general. He will also have to repay the government $82,000.

We want justice for SAF44 but we also want Purisima to be remembered as the 4-star CPNP whose star was removed because of failure to follow the laws of the land, for acting without authority and for putting to spot the institution of the presidency.

As to De Lima saying there is no chain of command in the police, it’s like saying the Justice Secretary is not aware of basic public administration principles. The Constitution clearly states that the President is the Commander in Chief of all state armed forces and the civilian government. Basic organization and management class would show this to the good secretary. When one draws an organizational chart, it informs the reader on the flow of instructions and information. It tells the reader on the vertical and horizontal relationships of each box. As former President Fidel V. Ramos emphasized, “I said it before, there are many chains of command—military, police, civilian, NGO, the media. The military [chain of command]is a bit different from the PNP chain of command, but both have one characteristic—the President is the Commander in Chief.”

Mr. President, “a man who has committed a mistake and doesn’t correct it is committing another mistake.” 44 lives gone, peace process stalled and you risk ending as a footnote. The signs on the wall are not good. Honor your oath. Honor, by telling the truth, the men you lost.


Please follow our commenting guidelines.


  1. >>> Kung wala makapagtatanggal ng 1 or 2 star kay Foolishima, BIGYAN NA LANG SIYA NG MGA STAR COURTESY OF PAMBANSANG KAMAO !!! NG HUWAG MAGISING TULUYAN.

  2. I find the material very objective and almost covered all bases. A President who realizes his mistake can take the unsolicited advice of Ms. Tiquia. It is clear it was the result of much study and analysis. Bravo.

  3. By the military code, what is the sin of Purisima? If it was the bypassing of the chain of command, it is clearly Commander-in-Chief who should account for that in this case, not him, as he was only observing the CnC’s “guidelines.” It was the ground commander who lost those men, and clearly that was Napenas. If his battle plan called for a reserve force of 300 men, it follows that if the shit hit the fan the reserves will AUTOMATICALLY be thrown into the battle, especially if his men are caught in a deadly trap. So why didn’t he? Because the CnC ordered him not to? Then he is a moral coward for looking out more for his career than the lives of his men. He did not need clearance from higher up if his battle plan was drawn up right, if it wasn’t, then its still his lapse that he will pay for with sleepless nights for the rest of his life. What if your children were trapped in a room thats on fire but you have an axe that you can break down the door with, will you still call up your husband for clearance to use the axe? Will you obey him if he is stupid enough to say “negative, negative”?

  4. yeah ms tiquia, your suggestion of stripping purisima of one star is a very good suggestion indeed. kaya lang wala namang gagawa nyan, not gazmin, not congress and certainly not boy sisi. lahat ng ito ay beholden kay boy sisi and they will do anything just to make boy sisi happy and free from harm. as to de limas, she will do everything by hook or by crook just to please boy sisi. she violated a lot of laws, including the constitution with regards to the hushed up cases agains arroyo, just to do what boy sisi wants done.

  5. All this legal manuevering including that of the congress and senate investigations will happen since Pnoy control both houses including the judiciary. Only a people power can put a stop to it. The arrogance of Pnoy with the legislative branch tolerating only challenges the will of the people. I hope someone will start a massive people protest to stop it.

  6. Leodegardo Pruna on

    The president as “Commander in Chef”, good only on war games on the tube. God bless the Philippines.

  7. A very good comment. Will those in position try to do your bidding? Let Sec Roxas make the first move of your suggestion. Let him make or break his political ambition to be one day a President of the country,

  8. I agree Purisma is a dusgrace to the Philippines and his stars must be taken away from him, immediately.