• The Brexit debacle teaches us all a few hard lessons


    BREXIT has destabilized the social, political, cultural and economic life of an entire nation. It has exposed Britain as a country divided between outward-looking metropolitan urban centers and disaffected, blighted hinterlands; a young, cosmopolitan, well-traveled generation that embraces internationalism and freedom of movement, and an older generation that clings to traditions of sovereignty, and is fearful of fluid borders and untrammeled migration flows. Why should any of this concern Filipinos?

    I have ridden the London bus number 52 since I was a child. The bus brought me to school. The route gives one of the best views of modern migration in the capital.

    Starting from the garages in the suburbs of northwest London, the bus sweeps by Pakistani, Bangladeshi, and Indian shops. There are signs in Gujarati and window displays of sari cloth, piles of sweetmeats, joss sticks and paan (betel and areca chew). Turning right, past the local library where the author Zadie Smith used to borrow books, the bus goes up, then down a hill, and follows the rows of workmen’s terraced houses that trendy hipster types are rapidly gentrifying and where fewer and fewer Greeks and Irish live. Pretty soon, we reach Ladbroke Grove, once a haven for post-war refugees—Slavs and Serbians. Later, a vibrant Afro-Caribbean community settled in the area but that, too, is now diminished.

    An assortment of Poles, Hungarians, Filipinos, Portuguese, and Latin Americans is now filling up the bus. Some of the Filipinos will get off soon to remit money at the Philippine National Bank’s office, a poky room above a shop in Notting Hill Gate. At Kensington, where the Philippine Embassy once was, some will change buses that take them to Earls’ Court, London’s Filipino enclave, or they will go to work in the grand, white-stuccoed houses that always remind me of wedding cakes, or meet friends in McDonalds on the High Street, a Filipino hangout since the 1970s. In nearby South Kensington and toward Knightsbridge reside French and American elites, and fabulously rich Russians. Nobody here is an “economic migrant.” This is “expat” territory. By the time the bus swings round Buckingham Palace and onto Victoria, the final stop, the passengers are mainly tourists. The Filipinos who are still on the bus are going to hear mass in Westminster Cathedral.

    The communities that populate this multi-ethnic wedge of London may or may not have voted in the Brexit referendum. Perhaps they could not care less about the EU. But the triumph of the “out” vote unleashed a vicious xenophobia that spits in the face of anyone brown, black, or foreign. Of course, not everyone who voted leave is racist, but the result certainly emboldened bigots, racists and thuggish vigilantes. Physical attacks, taunting shouts of “send them home” and “F*** off, we voted out” dog excrement pushed through letterboxes, the word “vermin” printed on flyers and plastered on Polish homes, “pack your bags” spray-painted on the walls of ethnic community centers, all happened just hours and days after the result. This is an outraged populism on the rampage.

    Filipinos in the UK are a head-down lot. None of them, so far as I am aware, has come forward to report incidences of hate crime or abuse. At least not yet. The Philippine economy, we have been told, will remain largely unaffected by Brexit. Mr. Asif Ahmad, the emollient British Ambassador to the Philippines, recently used some soothing words: “It’s not that we are suddenly shutting the gates to people moving.” But when every migrant is now becoming fearful, his assurances ring hollow. This is no time for complacency.

    Here’s why we should care and learn from Britain’s self-harming lunacy.

    First, when half the electorate is angry, alienated, and frustrated at being left behind, ignored, neglected, patronized, demeaned, and excluded from the wealth and rewards that globalization has brought to metropolitan centers, government has clearly failed. The out vote was an inchoate cry for change. Second, political jockeying for power among a bunch of opportunistic and self-serving elite politicians does lasting damage to democracy and recklessly gambles with everyone’s future. Third, both sides waged campaigns that were irresponsible, inflammatory, and fear mongering. Half-truths, misinformation, and outright lies were peddled, which sections of the press fueled rather than countered. Fourth, complex issues were reduced to bile-laced vulgar politicking, or crude and simplistic polarities—yes or no, for or against, in or out. Finally, the shooting on June 16, of Jo Cox the Labor MP and Remain advocate, cast referendum politics into the abbatoir. There is a short, direct and scary line connecting right-wing nationalism, isolationism and nativism that spouts from the mouths of certain politicians, or is propagated by some newspaper columnists, to intolerance and hate toward immigrants and progressives.

    It is this last point that is truly frightening. When neighbor turns against neighbor, an ordinary bus ride through the city has the potential to turn murderous. The Brexit mess has brought nothing but uncertainty and disgrace to Britain. We should care because when outward-looking cosmopolitanism is repudiated, when solidarity, civility and universal ethics are trashed, when deception, fear and hatred win out, everyone, and not just the Brits, is in serious trouble.

    My last week‘s column, “Burying Ferdinand Marcos,” erroneously stated that Lord Byron was buried in Kensal Green cemetery in London. I thank the reader who pointed this out. It is, in fact, his wife, Anne Isabella “Annabella” Noel Byron (Lady Byron), who is buried there.

    Twitter: @rachelaurea


    Please follow our commenting guidelines.


    1. “self harming lunacy”? As a Filipino living in the UK, I think one of the few good decisions by the outgoing PM is giving the people the vote. Majority of the Filipinos I know voted Leave. Why? Because the current system discriminates against Filipinos and other nonEU nationals and that must stop. Pantay pantay dapat ang laban, di lang porket European ka mauuna ka na sa trabaho, housing at kung anu ano pang benefits.

    2. arthur keefe on

      I am living in the UK, and followed the referendum closely. I voted remain, and am very depressed by the result. The writer describes very accurately the causes and consequences of the Brexit success. Those who hate or abuse foreigners are a very small minority, but many more did want the migration slowed. The problem is that the benefits of migration (3M entering UK and only 1M leaving over the past 5 years) have mainly benefited the better off. The disbenefits have mainly fallen on the poorer communities. No age group under 45 years old voted to leave, but many elderly people did, thinking they could recover the England of their youth. (Scotland voted by a large majority to remain.)

    3. Amnata Pundit on

      This is the mainstream media’s take on the Brexit victory, and just to let you know where you are really coming from, the mainstream media is the mouthpiece of the establishment/powers that be, Okay? The alternative take on Brexit is not about racism but about taking back their sovereignty from unelected, unelectable officials from Brussels whose real agenda is to establish a new Soviet Union in Europe in preparation for a New World Order where the current powers-that-be will control the One World Government. But this take is much too deep for a pundit who can only simplistically see things in black and white, like when they see Marcos as Darth Vader and Ninoy Aquino as Luke Skywalker. I suggest you stop watching tv to improve your analytical powers. Seriously, you will be better off reading Marvel comics instead.

    4. Maria stevens on

      The sad truth is that Britain has become a multi cultural and multi racial hellhole despite the protests of the indigenous ( white ) people..the whole world knows that the British are a kind and considerate people but this time they have been pushed too far and they have had enough!,,,,,,,,,,,,.

    5. Are you a Filipino citizen then? It seems that you were not exposed in your childhood to Filipino culture (at least to live here in the Philippines based form your article) … why should I then consider your opinion if at all? To me this is important, because as an opinion maker you directly or subliminally influence my countrymen, thus your heart and where it really stands is important. In short, maasahan ka ba na ang kabutihan ng bansa ang iyong tunay na interes, bago ko pahalagahan ang iyong mga isinusulat?

    6. Most of the articles I’ve read for them bremain argument was primarily about the economy. this is the first where I read an article that clearly the main reason to remain is due to racial issues.

      Do you feel that an exit from the eu will/is genuinely going to promote more racism within the UK?

      I thought the leave side is about having its own voice again for its own country, since the eu has been imposing more regulations and control over the 27/28 countries, more like a big brother/big government?