Home News Nation High court junks petition on same-sex marriage

High court junks petition on same-sex marriage

The Supreme Court on Tuesday junked the petition filed by a group of lawyers to allow same-sex marriage in the Philippines.

During the en banc session, the high tribunal decided that the petition cannot be given due course. The ruling was penned by Associate Justice Mario Victor Leonen.

This photo taken on June 06, 2019 shows members of the LGBT community participating in a mass wedding ceremony in Quezon City as part of the celebration of the Pride Month. PHOTO BY RUY MARTINEZ

The Office of the Solicitor General sought to junk the petition filed by lawyer Jesus Nicardo Falcis 3rd and his co-counsels. He asked the Supreme Court to rule as null and void Executive Order 209, also known as “The Family Code of the Philippines.”

The high court voted to dismiss the petition for certiorari and prohibition, which questioned the constitutionality of Articles 1 and 2 of the Family Code and asked to nullify Articles 46(4) and 55(6) of the same law.


The tribunal said the petition failed to raise “an actual, justiciable controversy.” It added that the matter of same sex marriage should be addressed to Congress.

The court said it recognized the protracted history of discrimination and marginalization faced by the lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, intersex, and other gender and sexual minorities community, and their struggle for equality.

“Same-sex couples may morally claim that they have a right against discrimination for their choice of relationships. Official recognition of their partnerships may, for now, be a matter that should be addressed to Congress,” the high court said.

Adjudication, the tribunal pointed out, assures arguments between parties with respect to the existence and interpretation of fundamental freedoms. “On the other hand, legislation ideally allows public democratic deliberation on the various ways to assure these fundamental rights. The process of legislation exposes the experiences of those who have been oppressed, ensuring that this be understood by those who are with the majority. Often public reason needs to be first shaped through the crucible of campaigns and advocacies within our political forum be sharpened for judicial fiat,” it added.

The petition assailed Articles 1 and 2, which “define and limit marriage as between man and woman.”

Falcis, a Metro Manila resident and a self-confessed gay, filed the case as a taxpayer’s suit, arguing those provisions “deprive [him] and other homosexuals the right to liberty without substantive due process of law” and “deny them the equal protection of the laws.” He also alleged that the provisions would declare gays and lesbians as “second class citizens.”

Robredo to release drug war report on Monday

Vice President Maria Leonor “Leni” Robredo confirmed that she will release her report on the government’s drug war to the public on Monday, December...

Jamaican wins Miss World crown

Jamaican beauty Toni-Ann Singh was crowned Miss World 2019 early Sunday in Manila. France's Ophely Mezino was named 1st runner-up, while India's Suman Rao is...

5 people dead in Quezon road crash

FIVE people were confirmed dead in a road crash in Pagbilao, Quezon on Saturday, police reported. Based on the report by the Quezon Provincial Police Office (PPO), five...

Magnitude 4.8 quake hits Davao Oriental — Phivolcs

A magnitude 4.8 earthquake hit Davao Oriental on Saturday afternoon, the Philippine Institute of Volcanology and Seismology (Phivolcs) said. Phivolcs said the epicenter was at...

UPDATE: 3 killed, 15 injured in Borongan ambush

A policeman and two civilians were killed and 15 were wounded in an ambush by at least 50 members of the New People’s Army...